More SPF for face

I haven’t been doing a whole lot in the sun so far this summer, so I haven’t gotten around to buying any other sport sunscreens. I’m still using that ThinkBaby Sunscreen SPF 50+ and loving it more every time, amazed that it smells so good every time! Here I’m reviewing a facial moisturizer, a makeup primer, and a BB powder with SPF.

Facial moisturizer with SPF: I had read good reviews for this specialized SPF moisturizer, Murad Oil-Control Mattifier SPF 15. Conclusion: Pending.

Murad Oil-Control Mattifier SPF 15

Murad Oil-Control Mattifier SPF 15

It’s supposed to control oily shine, so it’s made specifically for acne-prone skin and even contains willow bark extract, which has salicylic acid, to treat and prevent breakouts. It also purports to create a matte finish, acting much like a primer for foundation.

While I am all for treating acne and controlling shine, both huge issues for me, I don’t love all of the sunscreen ingredients — octinoxate and ensulizole in addition to the safe zinc oxide — so it’s not high on my safe sunscreens list. It also has an uncanny color, odor and consistency resembling Elmer’s school glue, so I can see why it would turn some people off. I haven’t used it consistently yet, so I can’t speak to its skin-clearing effects, but once applied the smell doesn’t bother me so much, and I have no complaints about it, though no raves yet, either. (Just FYI, I have been using as a moisturizer Pristine Beauty’s Hooray for Brallywood Butta Luxe Intensive Facial Creme, which has no SPF, but part of why I love it so much is the citrus smell, so odor does matter to me a lot.)

Time will tell whether I grow to like this particular moisturizer — if it indeed clears up skin, I will be a convert.

Foundation primer with SPF: Another product with good reviews, NARS Multi-Protect Primer Broad Spectrum SPF 30. Conclusion: Unsafe.

NARS Multi-Protect Primer

NARS Multi-Protect Primer Broad Spectrum SPF 30

I loved this stuff as a primer, actually, because it really did make my makeup last all day, but alas, this product contains the toxic sunscreen oxybenzone, which I was avoiding and didn’t realize was in this primer till later. Oh well, the search continues. (In the meantime, still using my regular non-SPF primer, bareMinerals Prime Time Oil Control Foundation Primer.)

BB powder: With a pretty low toxicity score as well as an affordable price tag ($13.95), the Physicians Formula Super BB All-in-One Beauty Balm Powder has replaced my regular everyday mineral makeup routine this summer.

Physicians Formula All-in-One Beauty Balm Powder

Physicians Formula All-in-One Beauty Balm Powder

This doesn’t indicate SPF, but it does contain both physical sunscreens zinc oxide and titanium dioxide that are in my bareMinerals Foundation SPF 15, so it may be comparable. In any case, I love this stuff! It provides more coverage than the tinted moisturizers I’ve tried, which I greatly appreciate, yet doesn’t feel heavy at all. I won’t speak to its beauty balm claims of being a moisturizer — I don’t think anyone using this should go without moisturizing before applying it — but it definitely reduces steps in my morning routine, plus it comes in a compact I can take with me to touch up during the day. And the price! I won’t have to shell out $30 for foundation and $20 for concealer at bareMinerals if this stuff continues to do as good a job as it’s doing right now. So happy with this.


Sunscreen updates

I’ve noticed that the Environmental Working Group has updated its sunscreen list for 2014, and since it’s also the summer solstice as well as a beautiful sunny day with temps in the 70s here in NYC, I figured it’d be a good time to post an update.

Beach/Sport Sunscreens

A few weeks ago, we rode our bikes to a baseball game on a beautiful sunny day just like today, and because I knew our seats were in the shade, I neglected to put on sunscreen, but I got sunburned on my arms and chest just from the bike ride to and from the stadium, being in the sun for about 80-90 minutes total. That led me to order this product online:

thinkbaby sunscreen spf 50+

thinkbaby sunscreen spf 50+

In my previous post, I had said I would definitely try the Badger sunscreen, because I love their Bug Balm and other products so much, and I still might do so, but the reviews on for the thinkbaby sunscreen were much better, so I had to try it. It smells good! It does seem to go on chalky white (it’s zinc oxide, after all), but it’s easy to rub in, and not overly greasy. I really like it a lot so far!

Makeup with SPF

As for facial SPF products, I do use the BareMinerals Foundation SPF 15, but recently I discovered that it is not rated well on EWG’s Skin Deep website anymore. (I am pretty sure it wasn’t rated that badly before, but it seems they’ve changed the ratings to take into consideration the amount of titanium dioxide in a product, and perhaps there is a lot of it in this stuff? I don’t really know.)

Since it’s summer anyway, and because I get some free samples by writing beauty articles for the bilingual magazine, I’m trying some tinted moisturizers with SPF: Revision Intellishade Broad-Spectrum SPF 45 and Laura Mercier Tinted Moisturizer Illuminating Broad Spectrum SPF 20 SunscreenSo far, I’ve found these products to be awesome in that they take so little time to put on, compared to my normal foundation routine, but I’ve also realized that I prefer the heavier coverage of the mineral powder makeup, because I like to conceal a lot of spots.

That being said, the Revision Intellishade is a nice strong facial sunscreen, but that means it also smells like a sunscreen, so I will probably not use for everyday sun exposure. It comes in only one shade because it is supposed to blend in with anyone’s skin, and I can’t speak for everyone, but it did blend well into my yellow-y Asian skin. A previous formulation of this was not rated well due to its inclusion of retinyl palmitate (vitamin A), which I mentioned previously is an ingredient to avoid in sunscreens because it reacts with sunlight, but the current formula does not contain any vitamin A, though it still claims to have anti-aging benefits.

The Laura Mercier Tinted Moisturizer Illuminating Sunscreen is buildable, so I can put on more for more coverage, but like I said, it still isn’t enough for me. Nevertheless, this is an excellent product, not smelly, not too greasy, overall super easy to use, though it’s probably more for people who are less sweaty and oily than I am, because generally I try to avoid looking so glowy. The regular tinted moisturizer would probably have been a much better fit for me, but that contains parabens, whereas the illuminating one does not.

Laura Mercier Tinted Moisturizer - Illuminating

Laura Mercier Tinted Moisturizer – Illuminating

Next up…

I hope to try a different beach/sport sunscreen (maybe a Badger one or something a bit more locally made) as well as moisturizers and primers with SPF, for those who don’t wear makeup or have SPF in their makeup.

Best-for-you sunscreens

Many people who know me also know that I recently started writing some articles for a Chinese-English lifestyle magazine, and that I began with a couple beauty articles on sunscreens and aftersun skin care. Some of my friends have asked when the sunscreen article will be out, because they want to know what sunscreens to buy.

Let me start with a disclaimer about my forthcoming article in said magazine: It does not reflect my own opinions about what sunscreens are best; rather, it was about so-called bestselling sunscreens, only it was really about bestselling high-end sunscreens, because of the demographic of the publication’s readership (i.e., wealthy Chinese-speaking tourists in NYC who buy luxury products). That’s why I’m writing this little guide to choosing safe sunscreens here.

My contribution to pushing safer products in that article was leaving out the ones on the lower end of the price spectrum that contained the most toxic sunscreen ingredient, oxybenzone, as well as any with retinyl palmitate (a form of vitamin A), which the Environmental Working Group states increases sun sensitivity and reacts with sunlight to speed the growth of tumors and lesions (not something I would want to put on my skin specifically to protect my skin from the sun).

Those two ingredients are the main ones to avoid when choosing a sunscreen. There are also a few other considerations (and I am taking these mainly from the EWG sunscreen website, which you can browse for more information):

  • Make sure it provides broad-spectrum (UVA/UVB) protection.
  • The best sunscreens are physical (not chemical), meaning the minerals zinc oxide and titanium dioxide.
  • Apply liberally and reapply frequently.
  • Avoid fine sprays or powders that can easily be inhaled during application.
  • Stay indoors or in shade during peak hours, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.
  • Wear a hat and sun-protective clothing, duh!

SPF ratings only indicate protection against UVB rays, which are the ones that cause sunburn. Scientists have found that, while UVA rays do not cause sunburn, they can cause skin cancer, so it’s important to protect against both kinds. Surprising to me was the fact that UVA rays can penetrate normal glass windows, which means it’s probably a good idea to wear sunscreen even if you’re not out in the sun a whole lot. (That being said, I don’t often bother with sunscreen for everyday besides my foundation, because I believe in getting vitamin D, but I might change my habits.) Of course, a low SPF of 15 would be sufficient for daily use, but the longer or more intense the exposure, the higher the SPF should be.

Mineral sunscreens have improved with time, so they are not all as chalky white as you may remember from your days lifeguarding in the ’80s or something. But some chemical sunscreens are OK to use, too, like avobenzone.

The EWG sunscreen website has a list of the best products, but there are seriously a lot to sort through, which is the kind of thing I like to do, but I understand most people don’t have the time or motivation to do so. (You can also look up the sunscreens that you already have at the EWG website.) Here are my picks, meaning the ones I want to try, because I have only used one of these so far. Some of these are among the bestselling on amazon, which one can take to mean they are well-liked but could also just mean they have better marketing.

Badger products are awesome, but I’d opt for Badger SPF 30 Unscented Sunscreen ($15.99).

Kids’ sunscreens that anyone can use: BurnOut SPF 35 Kids Physical Sunscreen ($17.99), Babo Botanicals Clear Zinc Sunscreen ($19.95), Thinkbaby Sunscreen SPF 50+ ($15.99), and California Baby Super Sensitive Broad Spectrum SPF 30+ Sunscreen ($20.95).

Logically, products designed for sensitive skin often exclude known irritants (such as many fragrances), as does Aubrey Organics Natural Sun Sunscreen, Sensitive Skin, Unscented, SPF 30+ ($15.95).

A sports-minded sunscreen preferred by marathon runners, cyclists, etc.: Sunology Natural Sunscreen Creme for Face SPF 50 ($14.99) and Natural Sunscreen Lotion for Body SPF 50 ($14.99).

Others to try
Elemental Herbs Sport Sunscreen SPF 30+ ($15.99)
Loving Naturals Clear Body Sunscreen SPF 30+ ($21.99)
The Honest Company Sunscreen SPF 30 ($13.95)
Block Island Organics Nontoxic Mineral Sunscreen SPF 40 ($32)
John Masters Organics Natural Mineral Sunscreen SPF 30 ($32)
MDSolarSciences Mineral Creme/Lotion Broad Spectrum Sunscreen SPF 50 (Creme $30/Lotion $34)

MDSolarSciences Mineral Creme

MDSolarSciences Mineral Creme

Daily facial moisturizers with SPF
DeVita Natural Skin Care Solar Protective Moisturizer SPF 30+ ($25.95)
Juice Beauty Oil-Free Moisturizer SPF 30 ($29)

Tinted moisturizers/makeup with SPF
Physicians Formula Super BB Cream SPF 30+ ($14.95)
Eau thermale avene Tinted Compact SPF 50 ($34)
BareMinerals Original Foundation SPF 15 ($27) (What I use because it feels like nothing yet covers everything!)
MDSolarSciences Mineral Tinted Creme SPF 30 Broad Spectrum ($32)
Sukicolor Tinted Active Moisturizer ($50.95)

Of course there are a lot of other good products out there, and I admit to using some that do not have the EWG’s lowest toxicity scores (most listed here have scores of 1 and maybe 2), but I’d say to just stay away from the worst ingredients and you’ll at least be reducing damage from harmful chemicals in some skin products.

I hope to update this blog once I’ve tried some SPF products!